The Roku Streaming Stick and Amazon Fire TV Stick aren't quite as powerful as their older siblings, but they're both great devices in their own right. In fact, if you don't have a 4K TV, you'll probably want to consider saving yourself $50 to $100 or so and going with a lightweight streaming stick over a full-sized streaming box. But which streaming stick should you buy? Here's our breakdown of the rivalry between the Amazon Fire TV Stick and the Roku Streaming Stick.

Cordcutting.com Reviews

Want the full details on both of these devices? Read our review of the Fire TV Stick here, and then read our review of the Roku Streaming Stick here.

Specs and Performance

The Roku Streaming Stick and Fire TV Stick are very, very close in terms of specs and streaming performance. Both top out at 1080p (sorry, 4K fans). Both have quad-core processors and point-anywhere remotes. And both devices received high marks in streaming quality in our Cordcutting.com reviews.

The real difference between these two devices isn't about what's under the hood – it's about the user experience. We'll explore that in these next few sections.

Operating System

Both sticks have great operating systems, but they offer two different experiences. Amazon's Android-based Fire OS has a bit more depth, but it's not as simple or user-friendly as Roku's OS. The Fire OS has more ways to customize and access your apps, and it has Alexa (Amazon's digital assistant) built in, which we'll cover in a moment.

Here at Cordcutting.com, we're on record as huge fans of Roku's OS. It's not highly customizable, but it's absolutely idiot-proof and it's very easy on the eyes. Of these two devices, the Roku Streaming Stick offers the simpler plug-and-play experience. The Fire TV Stick, on the other hand, is a bit more customizable – and a bit more complex.

It's also worth noting that the Fire TV Stick surfaces Amazon content in various ways throughout its OS. If you have Amazon Prime, you'll find that more tabs and options cater to you. Roku's platform is more brand-agnostic. That doesn't meant that the Fire TV Stick is only for Amazon fans, but it does mean that Amazon power-users will find more perks – and non-users will find some vestigial features.

Voice Search

Both the Roku Streaming Stick and Fire TV Stick have a voice search feature, but the Fire TV Stick's voice controls can do more than just discover content.

First, the Roku Streaming Stick: Roku comes with a voice search feature that lets you search for titles, actors, and more. It's an agnostic search – Roku doesn't have its own content to promote, so you'll just see your various viewing options listed in price order.

Fire TV Stick has Alexa, Amazon's personal digital assistant. Alexa is more than just a voice search feature: she can answer questions, launch apps, and even order Domino's pizza. If you're comfortable controlling your device with your voice, Alexa is a huge selling point for the Fire TV Stick.

Content and Apps

When it comes to streaming, nobody can touch Roku's channel library. Other than the recently released DIRECTV NOW, Roku has just about every streaming app under the sun (that DIRECTV NOW channel, Roku assures us, will be here by the end of this year's first quarter). Amazon's app store comes pretty close, but it's missing a few minor streaming services (NHL.TV, for instance).

Amazon has an edge when it comes to other types of apps. Roku is very streaming-focused, so the Fire TV Stick has the advantage when it comes to gaming (most of the games are casual, mobile-gaming style fare). Amazon also has some practical non-streaming and non-gaming apps, and some skills built into Alexa. A Roku can't order you some Domino's, but the Fire TV Stick can.

Price

The Amazon Fire TV Stick has the edge on price. At $39.99, it costs $10 less than the $49.99 Roku Streaming Stick.

Verdict

It's hard to go wrong with either of these devices, which are very similar. Generally, I'd recommend the Roku to streaming-focused users who want a simple and easy-to-use device. But there are a few types of people who will want to opt for the Fire TV Stick: if you're interested in light gaming, want to use your voice to control your device, really love Amazon products and services, or want a more customizable OS, the Fire TV Stick is the play.

3 thoughts on “Roku Streaming Stick vs. Amazon Fire TV Stick

  1. John Maggio says:

    The Roku does not support programs like Kodi. That in itself is enough for me to choose the Fire TV Stick. Of course I am biased, I have two Fire TV boxes. I like them better. They have more RAM, support 4K, have a wired Ethernet and USB port and can add a microSD card. The cost is $89 and is on sale for $79 often. So at $79 vs the $49 you get so much more. Just my opinion.

  2. Mark Matthews says:

    Just to alert everyone when you have the Terrarium Apk that essentially has the bulk of the content you can get on Kodi anyway which removes that advantage from the Fire Stick.

    One of the other key advantages I like about the Roku is the remote control. It seems to me to be much more fluid and agile than the Fire remote. And to me, having the best remote control experience is very important.

    Having said that, these are both superb devices.

  3. Jackie Stewart says:

    I’ve used both. I’ve had roku for several years, and used the fire stick off and on while waiting for certain apps to make it to roku (previously psvue; directv now, I’m looking at you). There is a lot more stuff on the fire stick, but that’s the whole problem. The user interface on roku is much simpler and more streamlined. If I want all the games and other things, I can go on the computer or tablet. One note, if you use vudu, it’s not available on the fire stick.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *