To keep this resource free, Cordcutting.com is compensated by certain providers listed below. Learn More To keep this resource free, Cordcutting.com is compensated by certain providers listed below. Learn More

Xfinity vs Frontier

Last updated: May 6, 2022

Starts at $24.99/mo
vs
Starts at $27.99/mo

Xfinity and Frontier are both major internet service providers, but not all ISPs are created equal. Which one is better for you?

Xfinity vs. Frontier in a Nutshell

Xfinity Frontier
  • Available in 40 states
  • Internet-only plans begin at $39.99 per month
  • Millions of public Wi-Fi hotspots
  • Available in more than 25 states
  • Internet-only plans begin at $49.99 per month
  • No data caps

Network Coverage Comparison for Xfinity and Frontier

One of Xfinity’s main advantages over Frontier is its availability. Xfinity is available to more than 112 million people in 40 states. With such wide coverage, Xfinity is the largest cable internet provider in the United States. If you aren’t familiar with Xfinity, you may know them by their former name (and the current name of their parent company): Comcast.

Frontier’s coverage reaches fewer people, and most customers with access are limited to the company's DSL network (rather than its speedier fiber network). With that said, Xfinity doesn't have overwhelming fiber availability, either — it's primarily a cable internet provider. Cable internet is generally faster than DSL but often slower than fiber.

Xfinity vs Frontier: Speed and Internet Performance

Technically, Xfinity has the fastest internet plan available to residential customers, with speeds of up to 2,000 Mbps. Unfortunately, fewer than 20,000 have access to that plan, and those that do may not be willing to pay its high price.

So what about real-world speeds? The bottom line is that Xfinity is faster. Its cable network is solid, and its fiber plans — while not all that widely available — are very impressive.

Frontier offers solid speeds in areas that it serves. Frontier’s fiber network originally belonged to Verizon FiOS, which is still the largest (and most impressive) fiber internet provider in the nation. Frontier's DSL offerings are not as fast. (Speeds could improve in the future; despite its recent bankruptcy, Frontier still plans to upgrade its current network).

Xfinity vs. Frontier Pricing and Plan features

If you’re wondering who has better prices, wonder no more: Frontier’s fiber internet wins the price war without a doubt. But some features — like access to Xfinity’s public Wi-Fi hotspots, a free streaming device, and a free Peacock subscription — are worth paying extra for. Besides availability, the choice comes down to your budget.

Frontier Modem
Frontier Modem

Compared to Xfinity’s prices, Frontier’s DSL pricing doesn't offer overwhelming value. While the multiple options make it a little easier to find the “sweet spot” in price, the value in terms of real-world speed doesn't always match what Xfinity can offer.

Xfinity vs Frontier: Equipment and Installation

Xfinity Frontier
  • Self-installation: Free
  • Equipment delivery fee: $15
  • Professional installation: $89.99
  • Equipment rental fee: $14 per month
  • Activation fee: $85
  • Self-installation: Free
  • Equipment delivery fee: $9.99
  • Professional installation: $75
  • Equipment rental fee: $10 per month

Both of these providers make self-installation free, but Frontier's activation fee makes even a DIY job a pricey proposition. Both ISPs will loan you a modem and/or router for a fee, but you can dodge fees like this by purchasing your own equipment.

Our Pick: Xfinity Is Your Best Bet

Frontier's fiber network is impressive, but it's not widely available enough to mount a serious challenge to Xfinity's broadly available high-speed plans. And while Xfinity's record for customer service is far from spotless, its reputation is improving, while Frontier's customer base remains somewhat less enthusiastic. Xfinity's pricing isn't necessarily the cheapest, but it offers excellent value for its speeds. Overall, we think Xfinity has an edge over Frontier.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.